Is this a real debate? lol
For the same money Muscleskins will make you a "made to measure" -- bespoke as it were -- fully cutomizable, well crafted garment.
Joe Snyder is great -- for your first thong. But if you are a connoisseur,,,
Once you want it to fit exactly right -- you go for Muscleskins.
Not only can you adjust the seat, pouch, rise, width -- but that guy has some great custom options (Drawstring only in alternate colors? Amazing.)but there are a ton of seats, pouches, strap widths -- all for the same price as a JS made in China jobber.
Lol -- he gets us.